Dear Ask a Ref,
I was wondering what happens when there is double penalties being called. Who gets possession of the ring?
Scenario: A1 had the ring. B2 checked and hooked A1, who then retaliated with an elbow. A1 lost possession and the ring floated into the goalie's crease.
ANSWER
When double penalties are called, play should be stopped immediately - you do not need to wait for a team to gain control of the ring. The ring will be awarded to the team that was receiving the first penalty as it's deemed that the second penalty is the one that causes the stoppage in play. In your scenario, Black would be awarded the free pass at center ice (penalties occurred in Team B’s defending zone).
Rule Book Reference: Section 19 - Consequences of Penalties
19.2 - Stoppages of Play
19.2.(c) If neither team is in control of the ring and both teams have a delayed penalty, play is stopped immediately when the penalty is committed by the second team.
Case: A1 passes the ring toward A2. B2 and A2 skate toward the ring. On the way to the ring, B2 slashes A2 then A2 retaliates by elbowing B2.
Ruling: Play is stopped when A2 elbows B2. The penalties are assessed and Team B is awarded the free pass in accordance with Rule 9.4.b.
The reference for the question below is: Ringette Canada Official Rules 2008-2011, Section 7, Point 7.8, p. 19.
"When two or more opposing players place their sticks in the ring and gain joint control, play is stopped if the ring is immovable or cannot safely be played. The ring is awarded to the team gaining second control.
NOTE: The ring is awarded to the team that did not initially control it if the player first in control momentarily removes their stick from the ring, allowing an opponent to gain control,and then takes joint control."
The rule doesn't specifically spell out who is awarded the ring if the player first in control does NOT remove her stick from the ring and continues to maintain some control.
When a two or more players (from opposing teams) place their sticks in the ring and it becomes immovable, the ring is awarded to the team that gained second control.
The note is simply stating that the player that had first control of the ring can not simply take their stick out of the ring when the other team puts their stick in the ring and then place their stick back in the ring and get the ensuing free pass, the rule and note are separate explanations, and one does not take the place of the other, they cover two separate situations.
Below are some case book situations from page 7-20 and 7-21 of the Case Book to help illustrate.
Case 1: A1 and B1 are trying to gain control of a free ring. B1 reaches the ring first and places their stick into the ring. A1, close behind, also manages to place their stick into the ring. The ring becomes immovable.
Ruling 1: Play is stopped and Team A is awarded the ring.
Case 2: A1 has control of the ring and is being checked by B1. Realizing that B1 will gain joint (and second) control of the ring, A1 relinquishes control momentarily, in order to allow B1 to put their stick into the ring. A1 then takes joint (and second) control of the ring. The ring becomes immovable.
Ruling 2: Play is stopped and Team B is awarded the ring.
Comment: If two players place their sticks in the ring simultaneously, then the player of the team that previously had possession of the ring has first control (possession of the ring has not changed). If the ring becomes immovable, then the player of the team that did not previously have possession of the ring has second control.